Rare Books Insider – Nov 26, 2021

Welcome to Rare Books Insider – FREE Version.

We use Moneyball tactics to discover undervalued, mispriced, and hidden gems in Fractional Investing.

The rare books asset class broke even on the year last week after a long recovery since spring 2021.

Last week’s performance

Fractional secondary markets

Two books traded last week on Rally: Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby 1st edition (+19.1%) and Carroll’s Alice in Wonderland 1st edition (+7.5%). Gatsby is still around 15% undervalued whereas Wonderland is now 143% overvalued.

All stats come from assets trading on the secondary markets at Otis, Collectable, and Rally


54 auctions sold $54 million last week.

The first printing of the final text of the US Constitution sold on Sotheby’s for $43,173,000 on 18th November 2021. A group of crypto enthusiasts made history raising $49m to buy the document, but they were outbid by Ken Griffin, CEO of Citadel. Griffin aroused ire in the online investor community in January when journalists discovered the trading app Robinhood sold trading data to Citadel.

Thanks to this outstanding sale, the average lot sold for $4,000 last week, which is a significant increase relative to what we typically see.

The Declaration of Independence IPO’d last week on Rally and closed out its $2,000,000 round. We put the inferred value of this iconic document at around $1m based on two sales of identical items in 2021.

A quasi-book was another large ticket item, as Heritage Auctions held an auction of space memorabilia. A micro-form version of the King James Bible sold for over $52,500. It was one of 100 gold-encrusted pendants made to commemorate Apollo 1 astronaut Ed. White II. White II had wanted to take a micro-Bible of his own on his space trip but had perished in a fire on the launchpad. This pendant was flown to the Moon in 1967 with Astronaut Edgar Mitchell.

There were also some notable lots to come out of last week’s Leslie Hindman Auctioneers auction:

  • A first edition of The Federalist Papers sold for $185,000 (3x estimate). The hit musical Hamilton has brought renewed interest to The Federalist Papers recently. They also of course are still a major source of debate today about the role of the Constitution, and thusly the sale may still be undervalued.
  • A copy of James Joyce’s Ulysses illustrated by French Master Henri Matisse sold for $23,750 (2x estimate). This was one of only 250 copies with Matisse’s illustrations, and the artist controversially never read the book. The illustrations were based on Homer’s Odyssey.
  • George Washington’s writings (edited by Jared Sparks) sold for $20,000 (2.5x estimate). President of Harvard at the turn of the nineteenth century, Sparks edited Washington’s writings extensively, changing entire sentences at times. This lot includes original letters and documents from other framers of the Declaration of Independence. Sparks’ cavalier approach to editing does blemish the value of these works.
  • First Editions of Dickens’ Christmas Books sold for $13,750 (2x estimate). It included his lodestar, The Christmas Carol, hence the sale price.
  • Several Lincoln autographs as well as a first edition of Chopin’s The Awakening sold within their five-figure estimates.
Matisse never read Ulysses. Who has, though?

This Week & Next Week

At Auction

eBay has some fascinating auctions which may rival the auction houses. Many are of 16-17th century books.

There is a copy of the Gutenberg Bible, Book of Haggai, from the Crawford Sterling Rare Bible collection with an asking price of $225k. An authentic 1579 Geneva Bible is listed at $849k.

A Very Good / Good 1st UK edition Harry Potter inscribed by the author is available for $14,000.

A 1st edition Wizard of Oz is also listed for $150k. A pre-production copy, it’s from the oldest-known batch of this book. Oz books overall have tripled in the last decade, and this was valued at $90k in 2001.

The same auction lot that included the Constitution includes several other American founding documents, such as multiple varieties of the Declaration of Independence, various state constitutions, abolitionist documents, Indigenous people constitutions, and even other forms of the Constitution itself. These will be up for auction this week.

The first week of December will be a very significant auction to watch: Heritage Auctions will be selling first edition rare books, many of which are also sold on Rally. Among these will be the first Harry Potter, the Lord of the Rings trilogy, the Chronicles of Narnia set, The Great Gatsby, Jane Austen, Ian Fleming, and Stephen King. Many of these titles are on Rally and eBay. We’ll be tracking these as the auction progresses.



Wyatt Cavalier

Wyatt Cavalier

With a background in finance & intelligence analysis, Wyatt has an unhealthy obsession with finding the best blue chip investment opportunities. His previous newsletter, Fractional, resonated deeply with subscribers, bringing actionable insights and unconventional trading strategies. His rare book collection specializes in banned editions. He currently lives in Spain with his beautiful wife, three young boys, and dog Monty.

Related Posts

national geographic magazine moon landing

Vintage magazines

We explore the market for vintage magazines, as Stefan shares anecdotes from collecting old issues of National Geographic.



Still, no bottom in sight for rare books fractional markets. Today we look into rare books performances, what’s at auctions offers, and the two new assets dropping in the marketplaces.

lord of the flies


Time to go book shopping? Today we analyze rare books fractional markets, limited edition books, and what’s IPOing this week and next week.
-William Golding’s Lord of the Flies

detective comics

Detective Comics #140 CGC 7.5 Cream to Off-White Pages

More losers than winners last week as more assets dropped into negative territory. The biggest loser was Batman #5 on Rally, which dropped 41%. Here’s what’s in store for you at auctions, comic books dropping this week, secondary markets, and more.

Recently Published

Curious about investing in Rare Books?

Get updates on new opportunities across Rally, Otis, and Heritage Auctions.

Join the club. Start here.

    Join thousands of subscribers.
    Absolutely spam-free.