BREAKING UPDATE – Mike Tyson’s Punch Out Buyout Offer

Welcome to Video Game Insider.

This is a new feature where we analyze a current buyout offer.

Mike Tyson’s Punch-Out – NES – 9.4 A+

punch out buyout

About the Asset

I wrote all about this copy and the similar copy that has been trading at Rally Road when it IPO’d last month. In short:

  • The Otis copy is also graded 9.4 A+ with No Rev-A, Round SOQ and Orange Bullets – it’s the 2nd earliest version.

It IPO’d just a few weeks ago for $136,800 and sold out within minutes.

About the Offer

Otis has received a net offer of $350,000, which is a 155.8% premium to the IPO. Otis has gone back and forth with their tax treatment so I don’t have an educated guess on what the gross offer was if it wasn’t $350K.

Recent Sales History and Valuation

When I wrote up the IPO, I conservatively placed a $212,000 value on it while acknowledging it was probably worth more (because the IPO was way less, I encouraged people to invest in it and invested in it myself). I also talked about the July auction, saying that a result of $40K or so for each of the two variations hammering at Heritage would be in line with that valuation. Well, one went for $84,000 and the other went for $78,000, indicating a 2x jump in value.

The 8.0 A+ mid-production that sold for $84,000 implies around a $400K valuation for a 9.4 A+ and the 9.2 A++ late-production that went for $78,000 implies a $120K value for a 9.4 A+ late production. Mid productions have generally goen for 4x the late productions so that would put the value at around $480K.

Now, keep in mind this $400,000-$480,000 valuation is for the Rev-A version (the same as Rally’s copy) — Otis’ copy is the No Rev-A version, an earlier variant that is probably worth 50-100% more — that puts this copy (with a wide error bar) at anywhere between $600,000-$960,000. There just haven’t been any sales of a No Rev-A version so I don’t want to put an exact figure on it, because in any case, its value is way higher than the buyout offer.

Inferred value – $600,000-$960,000


I own shares in this asset and I voted NO – the offer is way too low. Beyond the valuation discrepancy, I personally dislike when an asset gets bought out before it has a chance to trade. As Wyatt has helpfully pointed out, “The only reason to submit a buyout offer before an asset hits the secondary market is because you think it will trade higher in the secondary market.”

Also remember, Otis shareholders smartly turned down a $200,000 buyout offer of their Super Mario Bros asset that is now trading at a $465,000 valuation. VOTE NO!



Adam Katz

Adam Katz

Adam is a lawyer and real estate investor with a finance background. His diverse job experience includes stints in a MLB front office, a major global law firm and the real estate investment fund he co-founded. He is bringing his well-honed research and valuation skills to the world of fractional investing. Born and raised in San Francisco, he currently lives in Brooklyn with his dog, a pit bull mix named Beaux.

Related Posts

contra preview image

NES Contra WATA 9.6 A+

Today’s dive includes the only IPO from Rally this week: NES Contra WATA 9.6 A+, what’s trading on secondary markets, what’s at auctions, plus some industry news.

Recently Published

Curious about investing in Video Games?

Get notified on new IPOs across Rally, Otis, and more.

Join the club. Start here.

    Join thousands of subscribers.
    Absolutely spam-free.